
A 35-year-old woman said in an online post that her husband’s family has raised the subject of babies at nearly every gathering since her marriage.
In the Reddit post, her sister-in-law’s boyfriend commented on her anniversary gift and she now plans to skip Thanksgiving at the couple’s home.
The post is the only source for the account.
Woman Described Her Background and Job Loss

The user wrote that she and her husband, 41, marked their first anniversary last month. She described herself as a “highly independent, Type A immigrant” who paid for her own lifestyle before marriage and is the more financially savvy of the two.
She said she is currently out of work but has solid passive income and is focused on preparing for interviews. Since moving to the United States, she wrote, she had never been without a job. “This entire year has been mentally very debilitating for me,” the woman noted.
Reddit User Said In-Laws Pressed Her About Having Children

Per the post, her in-laws have been “relentlessly obsessed” with the couple having babies. She wrote that they raise it “directly or indirectly at every single social event.”
She called the attention intrusive: “My reproductive timeline has become a community project and our intimacy and family planning have become a matter of public discussion.”
She also wrote that male relatives “feel most comfortable pushing their interest in my pregnancy.” In her telling, female relatives “actively coach pre-teens (literal 11-year-olds)” to press the subject with her at social events.
“Is this normal?” she asked readers. She added a second question: “Is it normal for grown adults to push their agendas by using their own kids as crutches?”
Sister-in-Law’s Boyfriend Commented on the Ring

The user wrote that the breaking point came with her sister-in-law’s boyfriend, whom she called “John” in the post. She said he made “incredibly inappropriate and bitter comments” about her anniversary present, a gold-and-diamond ring.
She explained the gift in cultural terms. “Gifting gold is not only common in my culture, but being generous with presents is very normal to me,” the woman said.
In her telling, John “publicly audited our finances.” She said he complained that “men have a hard life” and told her she “set big standards for an anniversary present.”
Per the post, the sister-in-law then chimed in, saying the user had set “high standards.” The user wrote that the sister-in-law had made the same remark on a separate earlier occasion.
She also described a joke John made. He said her husband should give her a “string ring” to balance the gift, she wrote. In her view, this implied “I don’t deserve to be pampered.”
She added that John had made pregnancy comments since before she and her husband were engaged and had continued. “Rather obsessive for someone who’s not even family,” she wrote.
Boyfriend and Sister-in-Law Offered Job Help

After the ring comments, John turned to her job search. She said he offered to help her find leads. She was thankful; she wrote, “But honestly? No thanks.”
The user said he then pushed her to schedule a meeting with him and her sister-in-law the following day. “I didn’t even ask to schedule this!” she wrote.
A couple of weeks earlier, her sister-in-law had “generously” offered to set her up at the sister-in-law’s company so the two could review jobs together. The user described both offers as “weird handholding” and “infantilization.”
The user wrote. “I’m not interested in seeking favors, never have been the type of person to do so”.
She also asked, “Is it normal in American culture for in-laws to force favors?”
Mixing family and business, she added, brings favors that “rarely come without strings attached and a side of superiority complex.”
Husband Called the Boyfriend
The next day, her husband spoke with John by phone.
She wrote that he told him he had “crossed a line” and “overstepped” in criticizing the couple’s marriage. He also said she was “perfectly capable of finding a job on my own”.
Her husband had not yet raised the baby questions with the rest of his family. “That doesn’t make me feel particularly safe,” she said.
User Said She Disagreed With Her In-Laws’ Priorities

The user described what she saw as a contradiction. “They panic over a one-time gift but push us to afford a baby while I’m unemployed,” she wrote.
She listed what she had spent on herself before marriage: “$5,000 purses, $ 2,000 on weekend solo vacations” and “hundreds if not thousands” on clothes.
She also made claims about her sister-in-law and John. They “act totally self-made,” she wrote, despite support from their parents and community.
She said they have six children between them, including four from John’s two earlier marriages.
Per the post, her sister-in-law has asked the couple to watch her children since “day 1,” and the user wrote that the children have “5 active grandparents and 5 active parents.”
She also wrote she has always declined: “I have never seen more coddled adults”.
Woman Planned to Skip Thanksgiving
Holidays, including Thanksgiving, are hosted at the house her sister-in-law and John co-own, the user wrote. She said the couple had always attended with “good vibes.”
This year she plans to stay home: “I want to completely opt out to protect my peace.”
She said she told her husband he is welcome to go without her, because she does not want the guilt of him missing family time.
She acknowledged that her husband is “deeply attached to his family” and that she is attached to her own. Even if relatives comment on her absence, she wrote, “I have decided firmly to not participate in social events with people who cannot respect me.”
She ended with a question: “AITA putting my foot down and refusing to participate?”
Reddit User Added an Update About Her Husband

In an edit, the user wrote that her husband is “a very quiet personality” and that people often mistake that for passivity. “By no means does this mean that he does not stand by me,” she wrote.
She said he has defended her whenever she brought up these issues. She added that he is new to married life and she can “give him grace.” He still has not confronted the rest of his family and the two are “working through addressing that together.”
The post, she wrote, was meant to be about handling his family together going forward. “I am incredibly lucky to have my husband on my side,” the woman said.
She also said he may not always communicate actively but has supported her “from health and well-being to daily tasks and financial support.”