‘That’s Not What’: Bartender Serves Black Man Watermelon Drink After He Says ‘Surprise Me.’ Then She Realizes What She Did and Instantly Regrets It

Parenting Patch Staff

Brittany Norris recounted an awkward drink-ordering moment from her bartending days. BY: @BRITTANY NORRIS_/TIKTOK

A bartender said she realized within seconds that a drink she picked for a customer carried an unintended meaning. Brittany Norris, who posted as @brittanynorris_, shared the story in a TikTok video.

She said she served a Black customer a watermelon-flavored High Noon drink after he told her to surprise him. She said she picked the flavor because she loved it, not because of the man’s race.

Bartender Recalled the Couple’s Drink Order

Norris said the woman ordered pineapple while her husband asked her to surprise him with a flavor. BY: UNSPLASH

In the video, Norris explained how the couple approached her for their drinks.

“I’ll never forget when I was bartending, I had this married couple, a white woman and a black man,” she said.

When they asked for High Noons, Norris asked what flavors they wanted. The woman chose pineapple, while the man told her, “Surprise me.”

Norris recalled her response: “I get the goods, okay?”

She then returned with their drinks, telling the woman, “There’s your pineapple, my girl,” before handing the man a watermelon-flavored can.

Customer’s Drink Choice Made Her Rethink the Situation

The bartender said watermelon was her favorite flavor, but she later realized how her choice could be interpreted. BY: UNSPLASH

Norris said she had selected watermelon because it was her favorite flavor.

“I love watermelon,” she explained.

However, she soon realized that giving a Black customer a watermelon-flavored drink could carry an unintended racial implication.

The association between Black Americans and watermelon began after the Civil War, when many formerly enslaved individuals grew the fruit as a symbol of economic independence. However, white Americans later manipulated this association to create racist caricatures, depicting Black people as overly fond of watermelon and reinforcing negative stereotypes.

White Americans later turned that association into a racist caricature, portraying Black people as excessively fond of watermelon and using the imagery to reinforce degrading stereotypes.

Bartender Repeatedly Tried to Explain Herself

Norris reenacted her attempt to explain that she chose the watermelon flavor because she liked it. BY: @BRITTANY NORRIS_/TIKTOK

Norris said she immediately tried to clarify that she had not selected the flavor because she thought the customer would like it.

“I didn’t get it cause I thought you would like watermelon,” she said, before struggling to finish her explanation.

“That’s not. That’s not what? That’s not, that’s not. That’s not, that’s not, that’s not, that’s not,” she recalled him saying.

She then tried to reassure him and said, “I like watermelon. I love you.” The repeated attempts to explain herself captured how quickly an ordinary drink order had turned into an uncomfortable exchange.

Viewers Shared Their Reactions to the Awkward Encounter

Viewers shared their reactions to Norris’ account of the drink-ordering mishap. BY: @BRITTANY NORRIS_/TIKTOKK

The story prompted viewers to discuss the moment, with some saying they understood why Norris panicked, while many said they didn’t understand it or took time to realize what happened.

One commenter wrote, “I didn’t understand what you did wrong until the second listen”

Another said, “This is something that would wake me up in a cold sweat in 12 years.”

One said, “I knew what it was gonna be because I ALSO love the watermelon high noon, so glad this didn’t happen to me though!”

Another wrote, “This is the RIGHT AMOUNT of guilt. Thank you lol.”

Have a question about this article or other Parenting Patch content?