Missouri Man Helps Carry An 18-year-old Mom’s Casket While Her 2-Month-Old Daughter Survives. Then A Jury Finds Him Guilty: ‘He Got To Live His Life’

Parenting Patch Staff

James Barbier was convicted nearly 60 years after Karen Snider was killed, while her infant daughter survived the attack. BY: CALUMET CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT

An 18-year-old mother was stabbed to death in her Illinois home while her two-month-old daughter slept nearby. One of the people who helped carry her casket at the funeral was later identified as her killer.

Nearly 60 years after the death of Karen Snider, a jury found James Barbier, now 81, guilty of first-degree murder. The Missouri man was convicted on November 9, 2026, after investigators revisited the case and examined evidence using modern DNA testing.

Per CNN, Snider’s daughter, Paula Larson, who was just an infant when her mother died, spoke after the verdict. She said Barbier had lived his life for six decades while her mother never had that chance.

What Happened to 18-Year-Old Karen Snider?

Karen Snider was found dead in her Illinois home while her two-month-old daughter remained unharmed in her bassinet. BY: UNSPLASH

Karen was killed on November 12, 1966, at her home in Calumet City, Illinois. Her husband, Paul Snider, was working at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad when the attack happened.

When Paul returned home that night, he found his 18-year-old wife dead in an upstairs bedroom. She had been stabbed more than 120 times, per reports citing the autopsy and prosecutors.

Their two-month-old daughter, Paula, was in her bassinet in another room. She survived and was found unharmed.

Karen’s death left her infant daughter without a mother. Paul later raised Paula, but he died in 1989, long before the case reached a courtroom again.

Why Was James Barbier a Suspect in the 1966 Murder?

James had been questioned in the original investigation and later helped carry Karen’s casket despite being a suspect. BY: UNSPLASH

James knew the Snider family. He had worked with Paul and was friends with the couple. Prosecutors said he knew Paul’s work schedule and could have known when Karen would be home alone.

Investigators questioned James during the original 1966 investigation, but he was not charged. He later attended Karen’s funeral and helped carry her casket as a pallbearer.

That detail remained significant to the family. Paula later said police had noticed cuts on James at the funeral, which kept him on their radar.

Prosecutors also presented evidence about James’ behavior on the night of the killing. His then-wife reportedly noticed cuts and blood on him when he returned home.

She also said he went straight to the basement and started the washing machine, something she described as unusual for him.

How Did Investigators Reopen the Cold Case?

A 2022 tip led investigators to revisit preserved evidence and modern DNA testing helped identify James as a suspect. BY: UNSPLASH

Karen’s murder remained unsolved for decades. The investigation gained new momentum in 2022 after a man named Kevin Seeley contacted authorities.

He said he remembered hearing his grandmother talk about the killing while he was growing up and wondered whether new technology could help solve it.

Detectives reopened the case and revisited evidence preserved from the original investigation. They used modern DNA analysis to examine blood evidence and clothing connected to the crime.

The testing pointed investigators toward James. He was arrested at his home in Creve Coeur, Missouri, in April 2024 and charged with first-degree murder.

During the 2026 trial, prosecutors argued that the DNA evidence connected James to the killing. Defense attorneys challenged the reliability of the decades-old samples, arguing that the evidence had deteriorated and did not establish a definitive match.

The jury ultimately found James guilty after deliberating for about two hours.

Karen Snider’s Daughter Said He Got to Live His Life

Paula said James had lived freely for 60 years while her mother never had the chance to grow old. BY: UNSPLASH

Paula was only about two and a half months old when her mother was killed. She grew up without memories of Karen and learned about the murder through her family.

After the guilty verdict, Paula spoke about the long wait for accountability and the years James had spent free while her family continued to live with the loss.

“I hope that he never gets to breathe air outside again,” she said, per the Chicago Tribune. “He didn’t give my mother a choice, and he got to live his life for 60 years,” she added.

Paula also said the verdict came before more members of the family could die without seeing the case resolved.

“So many people have died in these 60 years. All that remains is the small family we have,” she said. She added that reaching a verdict before losing anyone else had been important to the family.

When will James Barbier be Sentenced?

The guilty verdict ended the trial, but James remained in custody while awaiting his December sentencing hearing. BY: UNSPLASH

James was found guilty of first-degree murder on November 9, 2026. After the verdict, the judge ordered his release revoked and that he remain in custody until sentencing.

He is scheduled to return to court on December 15. The judge also indicated that the defense would have the option to decide whether Barbier should be sentenced under current law or the sentencing guidelines in place in 1966.

The conviction came just days before the 60th anniversary of Karen’s death. For Paula and the remaining family members, it marked the end of a decades-long wait for a jury to decide the case.

Have a question about this article or other Parenting Patch content?