New York Server Tells Complaining Customers ‘I Could Probably Lose My Job for Telling You This.’ Then His Made-Up Tragedy Gets Him a 35% Tip

Parenting Patch Staff

A New York restaurant server claimed he received a 35 percent tip after telling complaining customers a made-up tragedy. BY: @DEANREDMONDS/TIKTOK

A New York restaurant server claims he received a 35 percent tip after making up a family tragedy to stop customers from complaining about their meals, per a TikTok video shared by Dean Redmond (@deanredmonds).

The incident gained attention on July 20, 2026, although the exact date of the restaurant encounter remains unclear.

Redmond explained how an ordinary dinner service reportedly ended with customers apologizing for complaints they had made earlier.

Customers Rejected the Server’s Appetizer Choice

Redmond said customers asked him to choose a popular appetizer after they struggled to decide what to order. BY: @DEANREDMONDS/TIKTOK

Redmond recalled approaching a table where customers were discussing which appetizer to order. Unable to agree, they asked him to choose something popular.

He initially hesitated, explaining that he preferred not to decide because they might dislike his selection. However, the group assured him they were not picky.

He eventually brought spicy fried calamari, only for the customers to complain that they disliked shrimp. After Redmond clarified that calamari was squid, they explained that they generally avoided fish.

He replaced the appetizer with two baskets of bread, which reportedly resolved the initial disagreement.

A Complaint About Chicken Piccata Prompted a Fabricated Story

The customers rejected the spicy fried calamari after explaining that they disliked fish. BY: @DEANREDMONDS/TIKTOK

Later, while Redmond was refilling drinks, a customer complained that his chicken piccata was dry.

The server offered to have the kitchen prepare another plate, but the diner declined.

Instead, he questioned the restaurant’s food quality, telling Redmond, “We’re just not having a pleasant meal.”

Redmond responded with an explanation he later admitted was fabricated.

“I could probably lose my job for telling you this, but our chef’s mom passed away yesterday and she’s the creator of that chicken piccata,” he said.

The customers reportedly appeared surprised. Redmond recalled one woman confronting the man who had complained.

When he returned with their drinks, the group apologized repeatedly and reportedly promised to leave a positive review.

Redmond claimed the customers eventually left a 35 percent tip. He ended his account with the advice, “Lie to them.”

The 35 Percent Tip Exceeded Typical Restaurant Gratuities

Redmond said the customers apologized, promised a positive review and left him a 35 percent tip. BY: UNSPLASH

The reported tip was well above the U.S. average.

Per Toast’s September 2026 restaurant tipping data, full-service restaurant customers left an average tip of 19.1 percent during the second quarter of 2026.

Redmond did not disclose the bill’s total or provide independent confirmation of the tip.

Viewers Questioned the Server’s Handling of Complaints

Redmond advised viewers, “Lie to them.” BY: @DEANREDMONDS/TIKTOK

The video attracted 34,300 views, with commenters divided over the customers’ behavior and Redmond’s decisions.

“Why give fish tho?? isn’t that hit or miss with peeps,” one viewer questioned.

Another wrote, “Every time that happens, then they wanna be picky.”

Others addressed the fabricated explanation itself. “Lying is the core of serving tbh,” one commenter wrote.

Another added, “Restaurant customers NEVER deserve the truth.”

The responses highlighted disagreement over whether Redmond should have handled the complaints differently, even as his account ended with a reportedly generous tip.

Have a question about this article or other Parenting Patch content?