To Top

    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies Recipe

    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies Recipe

    The holiday episode “How Lily Stole Christmas” episode of How I Met Your Mother is one of my favorite Christmas television episodes. After watching the show a few times, I came up with a sinfully cinnamon cookies recipe, inspired by the Christmas cookies that Lily makes for Marshall.


    • Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies1 cup of butter
    • 2 tablespoons of milk
    • 1 egg
    • 1/2 cup of packed brown sugar
    • 1/2 cup of white sugar
    • 2 1/2 cups of all-purpose flour
    • 2 1/2 teaspoons of cinnamon
    • 1/2 teaspoon of salt
    • cinnamon sugar


    1. Place the butter, milk, and egg in a large mixing bowl.
    2. Allow the butter, milk, and egg to reach room temperature.
    3. Preheat the oven to 375°.
    4. Cream together the butter, milk, egg, brown sugar, and white sugar.
    5. Combine the flour, cinnamon, and salt in a separate bowl.
    6. Slowly add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients.
    7. Shape the cookie dough into 1-inch balls.
    8. Roll the cookie dough balls in the cinnamon sugar. (Use colored sugar in the cinnamon sugar for more festive cookies!)
    9. Place the sugared cookie dough balls on an ungreased cookie sheet.
    10. Flatten the dough balls with a fork.
    11. Bake the cookies for 8 to 10 minutes or until golden brown.
    12. Immediately remove the baked cookies from the cookie sheet.
    13. Allow to cool completely.
    14. Store the sinfully cinnamon cookies in an airtight container.

    Butter, Egg, and Milk Sinfully Cinnamon Cookie Dough

    Rolling Out the Cookie Dough Sinfully Cinnamon Cookie Dough Balls

    Baking the Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies Baked Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies

    Image Credits

    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies Recipe © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Butter, Egg, and Milk © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookie Dough © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Rolling Out the Cookie Dough © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Sinfully Cinnamon Cookie Dough Balls © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Baking the Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies © 2012 Heather Johnson
    Baked Sinfully Cinnamon Cookies © 2012 Heather Johnson

    More in Recipes

    • Cinnamon Grinch Cookies Recipe

      I associate cinnamon with the Christmas holiday. I also love watching and reading The Grinch with my kiddos. I have previously...

      Heather JohnsonDecember 5, 2020
    • Fruitcake Recipe

      Loved by some. Despised by many. Fruitcake means the holiday season! Ingredients 4 ounces of dried prunes 4 ounces of dried...

      Heather JohnsonNovember 24, 2020
    • Chocolate Chip Potato Chip Cookies Recipe

      I recently had a dream about potato chip cookies. To my surprise, potato chip cookies actually exist! I therefore whipped up...

      Heather JohnsonSeptember 12, 2020
    • Easy Pickled Peppers Recipe

      My early autumn pepper harvest has been abundant. Because my guys like pickled peppers, I used the peppers that did not...

      Heather JohnsonSeptember 6, 2020
    • Peanut Butter Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Lactation Cookies Recipe

      Ingredients 1 1/2 cups of whole wheat flour 1 teaspoon of baking soda 1 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice 1 teaspoon...

      Heather JohnsonJune 21, 2020